Three women on the board can reduce corporate misconduct
Women in the boardroom are key to curbing corporate misconduct, according to a new study. When women gain influence, companies take greater ethical responsibility.
Kort oppsummert
- Researcher Muhammad Azeem Qureshi at Oslo Business School, OsloMet shows that having more women on boards reduces the risk of legal violations and unethical practices.
- The effect is strongest when the women are independent board members without ties to the company.
- Three women create the “critical mass” that ensures real influence and fewer breaches of regulations.
Parts of this text have been created using M365 Copilot. The text has been quality assured by OsloMet.
Corporate misconduct includes practices such as fraud, accounting manipulation, corruption, environmental violations, and serious breaches of labor laws.
“These violations can lead to massive financial losses, catastrophic environmental disasters, and even loss of human life,” says associate professor Muhammad Azeem Qureshi at Oslo Business School at OsloMet.
“The severe consequences show why we need research on how to reduce such misconduct,” he adds.
Fewer corporate penalties
Azeem has previously shown that companies with a higher proportion of women on their boards are better at complying with sustainability reporting requirements. These reports disclose how companies impact the environment and social conditions, as well as their internal governance.
Other studies have found that board size and composition can influence how ethically a company behaves.
“That’s why we wanted to examine whether having more women on the boards can reduce corporate misconduct,” says Azeem.
The answer was clear:
“Companies with more female board members receive fewer fines and penalties for misconduct.”
Women as sentry eyes
The study is based on U.S. companies, but Azeem believes the insights are highly relevant for other countries as well.
“Research shows that women tend to be more ethically conscious and caring. They place greater emphasis than men on the interests of the broader community.,” he explains.
These qualities also emerge when women make decisions in the boardroom.
“Women provide ‘sentry eyes’ on boards and pay close attention. They take responsibility for ensuring the company complies with laws and regulations and meets expectations from customers, owners, and other stakeholders.”
Azeemi also points to research showing that men often behave more informally when meeting alone:
“When women are present, the dynamic changes. Men become more disciplined and act more professionally.”
Independence matters
However, not all women contribute equally positively.
“The effect is much stronger when we’re talking about independent board members with no ties to the company,” Azeem explains.
Results are less favorable when women are employees of the company or appointed due to personal relationships.
“In those cases, they’re not as free in their roles.”
Independence alone doesn’t help
Azeem emphasizes that this finding is not about independence in general. Independent men do not have the same effect.
“When we look at all independent members combined—both men and women—the incidence of misconduct actually increases. That is a rather counterintuitive result.”
It is only when the proportion of independent women rises that violations drop significantly.
Three is the magic number
The study also shows that a certain number of women is needed on the board to influence decisions.
“If there’s only one woman, she often goes along with the majority and gives in to group pressure.
With two women, they start voicing concerns and have some influence,” Azeem says.
But the turning point comes when there are three women on the board. Azeem describes it as the critical mass – the minimum needed to make a difference.
“Only then do they gain real authority and influence. And that’s when we clearly see fewer company violations and fines.”
Taking extra ethical responsibility
The Researchers also found that the effect of women on boards is especially strong in sensitive industries where mistakes can have severe consequences, such as oil and gas.
The same applies to sectors under heavy public scrutiny and media pressure.
“In those cases, women take extra ethical responsibility. They don’t settle for meeting minimum requirements. They often go beyond what the law demands and help strengthen the company’s reputation.”
Ethics pays off
Azeem emphasizes that this is vital knowledge for future business leaders.
“For companies that want to reduce the risk of corporate misconduct and strengthen their reputation the recipe is clear: You need at least three independent women on the board.”
He also stresses that taking ethical responsibility does not conflict with profitability.
“Society cares about how large companies behave. Consumers value ethics and accountability. That’s why it pays for companies – both in the short and long term – to actively work on sustainability and social responsibility.”
References
- Muhammad Azeem Qureshi, Ammar Ali Gull,Tanveer Ahsan (2025). «Sentry eyes? Women directors and corporate penalties» (scinecedirect.com). Journal of Cleaner Production .
- Muhammad Azeem Qureshi, Sina Kirkerud, Kim Theresa, Tanveer Ahsan (2019): «The impact of sustainability (environmental, social, and governance) disclosure and board diversity on firm value: The moderating role of industry sensitivity» (onlinelibrary.wiley.com). Business Strategy and the Environment.
Featured research
- Working life, society and welfare
- Organisation, finances and management
Innovating together: Win-win partnerships between startups and corporates
Researchers have followed startups as they meet large companies and found two main paths to success and three common pathbreakers.
- Organisation, finances and management
Narcissistic leaders: Not always a bad thing?
Is it possible to make positive use of narcissism in the workplace and could it have any real benefits? Researchers have examined this in a new study.
- Health and social work
- Organisation, finances and management
Socioeconomic background of parents influences young people’s payment difficulties
The probability of young people ending up with debt problems is linked to their parents’ socioeconomic background.
- Working life, society and welfare
The welfare state has strong support among young people
Are young adults entitled individuals who won’t contribute to society? Not quite. According to new research, Generation Z are happy to pay their taxes.
- Working life, society and welfare
- Organisation, finances and management
The oil fund will not be there for our grandchildren
A close look at the principles governing the management of Norway’s oil fund shows that it may run out in two generations or less.
Forskningsartikkel av: Faculty of Social Sciences (SAM)
